What is the difference between Monel 400 and Monel K-500?

Monel 400 (UNS N04400) is a single-phase nickel-copper solid solution with 63 to 70 percent Ni and 28 to 34 percent Cu, supplied annealed at 25 ksi (170 MPa) yield minimum per ASTM B164. Monel K-500 (UNS N05500) keeps the Ni-Cu backbone but adds 2.30 to 3.15 percent aluminium and 0.35 to 0.85 percent titanium for Ni3(Al,Ti) gamma-prime precipitation hardening, supplied solution-treated and aged at 90 to 130 ksi (620 to 895 MPa) yield per ASTM B865. Corrosion resistance is similar; K-500 trades cost, machinability and weldability for roughly 4 times the yield.

Why is Monel K-500 stronger than Monel 400?

K-500 owes its strength to aluminium and titanium dissolved in the Ni-Cu matrix during a 980 degrees Celsius solution treatment, then precipitated as coherent Ni3(Al,Ti) gamma-prime particles during an 8 to 16 hour age at 593 degrees Celsius, furnace-cooled to 482 degrees Celsius. The precipitates pin dislocations and raise yield from the annealed 40 to 50 ksi range to 90 to 130 ksi. Monel 400 carries no aluminium and no titanium per ASTM B164 Table 1, so the precipitation route is closed; cold work is the only strengthening path and tops out near 85 ksi yield.

What is the price difference between Monel 400 and Monel K-500?

Monel K-500 bar typically sits 20 to 30 percent above Monel 400 bar by weight in the Indian market, driven by the aluminium and titanium additions, the longer melt route, and the mandatory solution-anneal plus age cycle. Premium widens on machined parts because K-500 hardens further during machining and demands lower feeds, slower speeds and more frequent tool changes than Monel 400. For flange bolting, HF piping and most wetted service where annealed 25 ksi yield is adequate, Monel 400 is the cheaper correct answer; K-500 is justified only where high yield is genuinely required.

When is Monel K-500 mandatory over Monel 400?

K-500 is mandatory when the design yield exceeds roughly 60 ksi (415 MPa) in a service that also needs the nickel-copper corrosion envelope. Typical landings: downhole tools and pump shafts in sour wells, propeller and impeller shafts in seawater, valve stems carrying high tightening loads, springs in marine and chemical service, and high-strength fasteners (ASTM F468 N05500) where Monel 400 Class 4 to 8 cold-worked grades cannot meet the load. For flange bolting at standard B16.5 tension, HF piping internals, brine handling and most plate-sheet-tube service, Monel 400 is the specified alloy.

Can Monel K-500 be welded like Monel 400?

K-500 welds, but the heat-affected zone overages and loses the gamma-prime hardening. Monel 400 welds in any thickness without post-weld heat treatment using ENiCu-7 / ERNiCu-7 fillers per AWS A5.11 and A5.14. K-500 needs the joint to be solution-treated at 980 degrees Celsius and re-aged at 593 degrees Celsius after welding to restore the aged yield, which is impractical for field welds. For welded fabrications, specify Monel 400. K-500 is for machined, threaded or hot-formed parts that ship in the aged condition.

Do both Monel 400 and K-500 qualify for NACE MR0175 sour service?

Yes, both nickel-copper grades qualify under NACE MR0175 / ISO 15156-3 for sour service at the 35 HRC hardness ceiling. Monel 400 (N04400) clears the cap easily in the annealed condition; K-500 (N05500) is age-hardened to roughly 27 to 35 HRC and must be controlled to stay at or below the 35 HRC limit. Both are listed in Annex A as acceptable CRA grades without prequalification testing for hydrogen sulphide partial pressure, chloride and pH within the standard envelope.

0091-22-66157017

info@torqbolt.com

Home

Monel 400 vs Alloy 20 (Carpenter 20) — Sulfuric Acid Service

Monel 400 (UNS N04400) and Alloy 20 (Carpenter 20, UNS N08020) are both engineered for chemical-process service but optimized for different acid chemistries. Alloy 20 was developed specifically for hot sulfuric acid in the 20-80% concentration range — its niobium-stabilized chromium-nickel-molybdenum composition resists chloride SCC where 304/316 fails. Monel 400 dominates HF and dilute sulfuric service. Acid type, concentration, and chloride content drive the selection.

Chemistry — UNS N04400 vs UNS N08020

Monel 400 = Ni 63 / Cu 28-34 / Fe 2.5 max. Alloy 20 = Fe ~36 / Ni 32-38 / Cr 19-21 / Mo 2-3 / Cu 3-4 / Nb (8x C min) — stabilized with niobium to prevent intergranular corrosion after welding.

Mechanical Properties

Property	Monel 400	Alloy 20
Tensile (min)	70 ksi / 485 MPa	80 ksi / 551 MPa
Yield (min)	28 ksi / 195 MPa	35 ksi / 241 MPa
Elongation (min)	35%	30%
Max service temp	480 °C	540 °C

Corrosion — Acid-by-Acid

Alloy 20 wins on: sulfuric acid 20-80% concentration at temperatures up to 80°C, phosphoric acid (all conc.), nitric acid, mixed-acid chemistries. Chromium + molybdenum + niobium combination resists pitting and IGC.

Monel 400 wins on: hydrofluoric acid (any conc.), dilute sulfuric (< 20%), hot seawater, ammonia, caustic. Alloy 20 has chromium — fails in HF.

Cost & Lead Time

Alloy 20 typically 1.5-2x Monel 400 raw stock. Alloy 20 fittings widely stocked in US/EU chemical-process supply chains. Lead time similar 4-12 weeks. Quote both alloys.

Applicable Standards

Monel 400: ASTM B127/B164/B165/F468
Alloy 20: ASTM B463 (sheet/plate), B473 (rod/bar), B729 (pipe), B366 (fittings); ASME SB-463/473/729

Selection Guide

Pick Alloy 20 for 20-80% H₂SO₄ service, chloride-containing acid streams, sulfuric pickling, or chemical-process duty mixing sulfuric + nitric. Pick Monel 400 for HF, dilute sulfuric, hot seawater, ammonia. For ambient sulfuric < 20% both work; cost decides.

FAQs

Why is Alloy 20 stabilized with niobium?

Niobium ties up free carbon by forming NbC carbides, preventing chromium-carbide precipitation at grain boundaries during welding. Without stabilization, Cr₂₃C₆ at grain boundaries causes intergranular corrosion in hot acids. Monel 400 has no chromium and doesn't need this stabilization.

Can Monel 400 replace Alloy 20 in sulfuric acid > 80%?

Yes, with caveats. Above 80% H₂SO₄ the acid becomes oxidizing and both Monel and Alloy 20 are usable. Below 80% (and especially with chlorides), Alloy 20 is the better choice. For concentrated > 96% sulfuric, carbon steel or cast iron is actually preferred — passivation favors uncoated mild steel.

Is Alloy 20 the same as Inconel?

No. Inconel is a brand name for Ni-Cr-Fe and Ni-Cr-Mo alloys (e.g., 600, 625, 718). Alloy 20 is iron-based with ~36% nickel — closer to a stainless steel than an Inconel.

Which is easier to machine?

Alloy 20 machines more like 304/316 stainless (work-hardening but predictable). Monel 400 work-hardens aggressively and requires sharp tooling + positive rake + flood coolant. Both are workable; Alloy 20 is more familiar to a typical stainless-shop operator.

Xylan 1070 / 1014 / 1400 / 1424

Xylar 2 / 101

Geomet 321 / 500 / 720

SermaGard 1105 / 1280

Dacromet 320 / 500

TakeCoat 1000 Ceramic

Delta Tone/Seal

Magnigard

MolyKote

Sherardized

Zinc-Cobalt (ASTM B840)

Zinc-Nickel (ASTM B841)

ISO 9001 - 2015 Certified
PED 2014/68/EC
NACE MR0175/ISO 15156-2
NORSOK M-650
DFAR
MERKBLATT AD 2000 W2/W7/W10

Questions? Contact us.

Showcase of our Microsites.

Monel 400 vs Alloy 20 (Carpenter 20) — Sulfuric Acid Service

Chemistry — UNS N04400 vs UNS N08020

Mechanical Properties

Corrosion — Acid-by-Acid

Cost & Lead Time

Applicable Standards

Selection Guide

FAQs

Specifications

Surface Treatments

Certifications

About Us

Satisfaction Survey

Monel 400 vs Alloy 20 (Carpenter 20) — Sulfuric Acid Service

Chemistry — UNS N04400 vs UNS N08020

Mechanical Properties

Corrosion — Acid-by-Acid

Cost & Lead Time

Applicable Standards

Selection Guide

FAQs

Related

Specifications

Surface Treatments

Certifications

About Us

Satisfaction Survey